The Evidenceconnecting the dots betweenTwo Johns

 

Return to Site Map

 

 

What does the evidence tell us?

 

As a whole, the evidence tells us there was one John Knox who lived on the headwaters of McDowell Creek in Caldwell between 1800 and 1860, and that John Knox was the son of Captain Patrick Knox:

 

 

Captain Patrick Knox’s estate papers provide these documented facts:

 

1.     Patrick Knox was “kiled” in June 1780 – which confirms this is the Capt Patrick Knox of Mecklenburg, who lost his life in the Revolution at the Battle of Ramseur’s Mill.

2.     His widow Mary married Alison Knox, who became Administrator of Patrick’s Estate, but no relationship to Alison is stated.

3.     His widow Mary had a brother named “Smith” indicating her surname was probably Smith.

4.     His children were Hannah, Matthew, Ruth, John and Jane.

5.     In 1795, Samuel Wilson was married to one heir (Hannah) and guardian of two others (John & Jane).

6.     In 1800, John Knox was the ‘only’ heir to the land owned by his father, in which John’s mother had “lifetime” dower interests.

 

 

Mecklenburg Deeds clearly identify John Knox, son of Patrick Knox, owned land on McDowell Creek before July 1800:

 

1.     In July 1800, within a few days of closing his father’s estate, John Knox sold 423 acres to Samuel Wilson on the “East side of the Catawba River, which included his father’s 373-acres purchased in 1779 from Archibald Henderson, adjoining John and William Henderson.  The other 50 acres were John’s own State Land Grant which adjoined his father’s property

2.     On the same day, John Knox purchased from Samuel Wilson 384 acres on McDowell Creek, adjoining Martin Steele, Adam Meek, William Hill, Dunlap, Samuel Wilson and himself…John Knox #1.

3.     In 1822, Samuel Wilson deeded (not sold) to John Knox an additional 32 acres on the “headwaters” of McDowell Creek as part of a “previous” agreement.

 

 

Other Mecklenburg County Documents for John Knox #1:

 

1.     John Knox was Administrator for the Estate of Jane Knox who died intestate in 1818; Samuel Johnston and David Smith both served as John’s Security Bondsman. 

2.     Jane Knox’s 1818 Estate Papers show Alison Knox owed an account to her estate; Moses Shelby was among the buyers at her Estate Sale.

3.     No relationships given in Jane’s estate papers; however, she appears to be Jane the sister of John #1, stepdaughter of Alison Knox, and sister-in-law of Moses Shelby.

4.     John Knox was appointed 1826 Guardian of Moses Shelby’s minor children  [Note: In the 1830s, several of Moses and Mary Ann (Knox) Shelby’s children and grandchildren appear in Bethel Church Records, where John Knox #2 was a Trustee in 1829 – the only John Knox at Bethel...]

 

 

All of the above transactions are clearly John Knox, son of Patrick – John Knox #1; however, Samuel Johnston [item 1 above] was married to Louisa Henderson, 2nd cousin of Polly B. Robison, wife of John Knox #2. The following transactions are identified as John Knox #2:

 

 

Bethel Presbyterian Church Session Book No. 2 records document John Knox #2’s presence at Bethel as early as 1832:

 

1.     In April 1832, John’s man named “Jim” was a Communicant.  Two of Jim’s sons were baptized at Bethel (Robert Franklin, February 1835 & Richard Baxter, May 1858).  In all three cases, J. or Jno. Knox is shown as Jim’s “Master.”  Jim is bequeathed to son Andrew in John’s LWT, item 8.

 

 

Mecklenburg Deeds document John Knox #2 as a Bethel Trustee in 1829, and living on the “headwaters” of McDowell Creek as early as 1816:

 

1.     An 1829 deed transaction confirms the Knox Tradition that John Knox was a Charter Member of Bethel Presbyterian (1828/1829).   The Deed lists John Knox among the “Trustees of Bethel” in the purchase of 5 acres on Beaverdam Creek.

 

2.     The 1823 Tax List for Capt Doherty’s Company, documents John Knox owned 300 acres in Mecklenburg for that tax year, and provides a list of his neighbors.

 

3.     The original 1816 deed for 105 acres which John Knox owned (twice!) on the “headwaters” of McDowell Creek is in the possession of great-great-grandson, who believes this deed is for property on Bailey Road where the “Old” Robert J. Wilson home place once stood; however the acreage does not match John’s reference to 126 acres.  It is possible that in 1846, the 126-acre tract sold to Robert J. Wilson Knox included this 105 acres…combined with an additional 21 acres, but we cannot confirm this. I suspect the 126 acres +/- is a combination of the 105 acres +/- and the 23 acres +/- John purchased in 1835 from Sarah B. Johnston, an heir of Andrew Johnston. The 1816 deed also states the tract was a subdivision of the plantation where John Knox “now lives”…   

 

 

Other Mecklenburg Documents as early as 1813:

 

1.     The earliest confirmation of John Knox #2’s presence in Mecklenburg is his 1813 Marriage Bond to Polly B. Robison.  Marriage Bonds were made in the county of the bride’s residence, so John may have lived elsewhere. [If Mary B’s surname is a surprise to you, go here for More about Mary “Polly B” Robison’s ancestry...]

 

 

By 1816, according to the deed wording, John Knox #2 is living on McDowell Creek. More importantly, there are no other deeds for “a” John Knox purchase of land on the McDowell Creek after John Knox #1’s purchase in 1800 and before 1816…and all later transactions can be identified as John Knox #2.

 

 

 

Transactions for John Knox between 1800 thru 1853:

 

If the 1816 Deed is John Knox #2, then, when, and from whom, did John Knox #2 acquire his “plantation” on the headwaters of McDowell Creek where he was living in 1816? There was only one John on the headwaters of McDowell Creek in the 1823 Tax list, and he owned 300 acres.  Moreover, what happened to the 384 acres that John Knox #1 owned on McDowell Creek in 1800? 

 

Looking at the 1800-1853 transactions below, I think the answer is clear. John’s 1816 home was located on either the land John Knox #1 purchased from Samuel Wilson in 1800, or the land John #1 already owned in 1800 which adjoined it.   In my opinion, there is no room for two Johns on the “headwaters of McDowell Creek”…

 

 

 

 

Date

 

Who

 

Description

 

 

Document

 

10 July 1800

John Knox to

Samuel Wilson

423 A in 3 parts on East side of Catawba River, (373 acres of which previously owned by Patrick Knox)

Deed Bk 16, pg 461

10 July 1800

Samuel Wilson to

John Knox

384 A in 3 parts on McDowell Creek adj Martin Steel; Adam Meek, Wm Hill, Dunlap; Samuel Wilson and John Knox himself

Deed Bk 16, pg 460

1801

John Knox to

David Smith

Unknown Acres on McDowell Creek adj Martin Steel

[Smith subsequently combined with other land and sold to Absalom Duckworth in Oct. 1804]

No Deed found, but sale referenced in

Deed Bk 22, pg 128

21 Aug 1805

John Knox to

Robert Dunlap

53 A on head of McDowell Creek adj James Curry and John Knox himself

Deed Bk 20, pg 95

Nov 1813

John Knox to

Polly B. Robison

Marriage Bond; James A. Todd, Bondsman

Mecklenburg  Co, NC Marriage Bonds

25 Dec 1816

John Knox to

William Elliott

105 A on waters of McDowell Creek – subdivided from plantation on which John Knox now lives; adj Steel, Andrew Johnston, and John Knox himself

Deed Bk 21, pg 36

25 May 1822

Sam. Wilson to

John Knox

32 A on headwaters of McDowell Creek; adj the Great Road, Dr. Joseph McKnitt Alexander, Adam Meek, decd and John Knox himself

Deed Bk 23, pg 233

1823-1824

Capt Doherty’s Tax Lists

John Knox owned 300 acres; 1 WP & 2 BP

Assuming all 300 acres was on the headwaters of McDowell Creek, we can back into the acreage John owned prior to 1800: 300-(384+32-103+311)=11 acres

 

4 Dec 1826

LWT of Moses Steel

[son of Martin Steele/Steel]

"...it is my will that my exrs sell...my property...including 25 A adj Martin Steel's old place, Hugh Smith, and John Knox...”

Mecklenburg Co, NC Wills: Bk C, pg 4

25 Jan 1828

Ephraim Jetton/

John Knox

105 A on McDowell Creek adj Andrew Johnston

Deed Bk 23, pg 233

24 Jan 1835

Sarah B. Johnston

[heir of Andrew Johnston]/

John Knox

23 A on headwaters of McDowell Creek adj James H. Houston [James died in 1826, so this was actually his widow Sarah Davidson Kerr who later married Wm. Lee Davidson II and moved to Marengo Co, AL] and John Knox himself

Deed Bk 25, pg 433

31 Aug 1835

John Knox/

Andrew Springs

14 A. adj. James Smith & the Statesville Road

Deed Bk 25, pg 461

1 Feb 1845

Land Divison of Estate of Robert Robison/

John and Mary B. Knox

98 A (Lot No. 5) adj Archibald Robinson, the Great Road, C. H Robinson, Jas P. Henderson, Sample, and various courses of a branch [need to get deed copy]

Court Minutes:

Bk 9; 244

[description from estate papers]

31 May 1845

Archibald Robison/

John Knox

7 ½ A adj David Henderson, John Knox himself and others, being a part of the tract of land of Robert Robison, decd

Deed Bk 2nd 2, pg 224

31 May 1845

Cynthia H. Robison/

John Knox

20 ½ A adj David R[obison]. Henderson, the Great Road, C. H. Robison, and others

Deed Bk 2nd 2, pg 231

Aug 1845

R. J. W. Knox to

Martha N. Jetton

Marriage Bond; Sherod Little, Bondsman

Mecklenburg Co, NC

Marriage Bonds

7 March 1846

John Knox/

Robert J. W. Knox

126 A on headwaters of McDowell Creek; adj William [Graham] Potts and John [Milton] Alexander

Deed Bk 2nd 2, page 108

24 Aug 1852

John Knox & Mary B. Knox/

David S. Hutchison

110 ¼ acres [probably Robert Robison property above - need to get deed copy]

Court Minutes:

Bk 10: 271

25 Jun 1853

LWT of John Knox

3rd I give and bequeath to my Daughter Mary B. Smith One Note on David S. Hutchinson for the amount of One hundred Dollars

Mecklenburg Co, NC Wills:

Bk J, pg 89

 

 

 

 

 

Fingerprints and signatures…

 

Sorry, no fingerprints…but we do have signature evidence:

 

 

The “John Knox” Signatures…

 

Original Documents:

 

1.     John and Polly B’s 1813 Mecklenburg Marriage Bond has John’s original signature. 

2.     The 1816 Original Deed of Sale from John Knox to William Elliot has John’s original signature. 

3.     Jane Knox’s 1818 Estate Papers has John Knox’s original signature. 

4.     John Osborn’s 1823 Estate Admin Bond has John Knox’s original signature.

5.     Hugh Bryson’s 1833 Guardianship Bond has John Knox’s original signature.

6.     John Knox’s 1853 Last Will & Testament has John Knox’s original signature.

 

Yes, all four are John Knox’s signature, but which John?

 

1.     Document 1 is proven to be John Knox #2. 

2.     Document 2 is in the possession of John Knox #2’s descendant, which circumstantially indicates this is the signature of John Knox #2 

3.     Document 3 must be John Knox # 1, brother of Jane Knox, daughter of Patrick Knox

4.     Document 4 could be either John Knox #1 or #2; John Osborne was a McDowell Creek neighbor

5.     Document 5 could be either John Knox #1 or #2, Hugh Bryson was a McDowell Creek neighbor

6.     Document 6 is proven to be John Knox #2

 

The time span from the first to the last signature is 40 years, and the last is that of an obviously feeble person.  However, the first three are all relatively early, and within a five-year period. What are the odds that two John Knoxes would have a signature so similar? To my untrained eye, all of these signatures appear to have been penned by the same hand…and if they were, they would provide proof John Knox #1 and John Knox #2 are the same person.   

 

 

 

Circumstantial evidence….

 

 

John and Polly B’s children…

 

Genealogists often use “naming tradition” rules as a tool for narrowing the search for parents.  Here is the standard Scots-Irish naming tradition:

 

First son after father's father

Second son after mother's father

Third son after father

Fourth son after father's oldest brother

Fifth son after mother's oldest brother

First daughter after mother's mother (or father's mother)

Second daughter after father's mother (or mother's mother)

Third daughter after mother

Fourth daughter after mother's oldest sister

Fifth daughter after father's oldest sister

 

 

Hmmm…this pattern doesn’t seem to work with John and Polly B’s children:

 

First son - Robert J. Wilson Knox [b. 1820]

 

Possible namesake: Polly B’s father, Robert

 

None of Robert J. Wilson Knox’s papers tell us what the initial “J” was for, but the “Wilson” probably honored Samuel Wilson, John’s brother-in-law and former guardian, who was about the same age as John’s natural father and perhaps was his “father figure” for most of his life.  John was only 3 when his father was killed in the Revolution, so he never really knew his father.

 

Second son - Patrick Jefferson Knox [b. 1823]

 

Probable namesake: John’s father, Patrick Knox

 

It’s interesting to note that John’s sister Hannah and her husband Samuel Wilson named their second son Patrick Jefferson Wilson, born about 1806.  Thomas Jefferson was President from 1801-1809, and was a popular namesake during this timeframe, so that may be the source of “Jefferson” as a middle name.

 

 

Second son – John R. Knox [b. 1830]

 

Probable namesake: John, himself, with Polly B’s surname…Robison

 

Polly B also had an uncle named John Robison. No documents leave a clue as to what the initial “R” might have stood for, but a common tradition was using the mother’s surname as a middle name for at least one child, and often several. 

 

Third son – Andrew Springs Knox [b. 1834]

 

Certain namesake: Andrew Springs

 

Bethel Church records document Andrew Springs Knox’s complete name.  Andrew Baxter Springs was a Caldwell Station neighbor, and a Ruling Elder at Bethel.  One of his three wives was Louisa Henderson, near-kin of Polly B, so there is a loose family connection here, too.

 

 

First Daughter – Margaret Knox [b. abt 1814]

 

            Probable namesake: Polly B’s mother, Margaret [Henderson] Robison

 

Again, John and Polly B did not follow the Scots-Irish naming tradition…or their first daughter would have been named Mary... 

 

 

Second Daughter – Mary B. Knox [jr] [b. abt 1817]

 

            Certain namesake:  Mary, herself, and John’s Mother, Mary (Smith) Knox

 

 

Third Daughter – Hannah E. [b. Nov 1827]

 

Probable namesakes: John’s eldest sister Hannah (Knox) Wilson.  I speculate the E was for Elizabeth...and if so, her second namesake was probably Polly B’s eldest sister Elizabeth (Robison) Gillespie/Alexander.

 

 

All of the above is circumstantial and speculative, but certainly provides food for thought!  In my opinion, the use of the given name Patrick is a very compelling piece of circumstantial evidence, since there are no other Patrick Knoxes found in the other Mecklenburg Knox lines…all are found in John #2 line.

 

 

 

 

McDowell Creek and Caldwell Deeds…both hard and circumstantial…

 

The 1816 Deed is the key evidence connecting John #1 to John #2 – not only because of its signature, but because of its location and date.  It presents hard evidence that John Knox #2 was living on his McDowell Creek property, and had neighbors named “Steel” and Andrew Johnston.

 

Martin Steele died in 1817 but was an adjoining landowner on the John Knox #1 July 1800 purchase on McDowell Creek.  Martin Steele’s land was later divided among his children, who continued to be John Knox’s neighbors for many generations.

 

Captain Doherty’s 1823 Tax Lists includes individuals associated with John #1, John #2, or both.

 

In 1835, John Knox #2 purchased 23 acres (adjoining his own property) from Sarah B. Johnston Murray, heir of Andrew Johnston.

 

Looking at the transaction timeline table below, a clear pattern emerges: 

 

John Knox #1 [PINK] first appears on McDowell Creek in July 1800…but then merges with John Knox #2 as early as 1805 [LAVENDER]…since Robert Dunlap and James Curry are associated with John Knox #1, but the deed witness Daniel McAuley is associated with John Knox #2…  By 1816, John Knox #2 [BLUE] is clearly living on the headwaters of McDowell Creek. 

 

The John Knox who emerges is John Knox #2, with the exceptions of the 1818 Jane Knox Estate, which includes Samuel Johnston who is associated with both John Knox #1 and #2, and the 1826 Guardian Bond for Moses Shelby’s children – which is clearly John Knox #1...but attended the church associated with John Knox #2.  Notice that from 1800 to the present-day Caldwell Station Knoxes, Martin Steele’s property and descendants are consistently nearby...

 

 

 

When

 

Who/What

 

Which John?

1794

James Curry was the Security Bondsman for Samuel Wilson’s 1794 Guardianship Bond for John and Jane Knox, orphans of Capt Patrick Knox.

 

1

 

10 July 1800

John Knox, son of Patrick, sold his father’s 424 acres on the “east side of the Catawba River” to Samuel Wilson, his brother-in-law.

 

1

10 July 1800

John Knox purchased 384 acres on McDowell Creek from Samuel Wilson.  It was comprised of three parts, one of which was a 13-acre tract adjoining Martin Steele and Adam Meek. William Hill and “Dunlap” adjoin other parts of the 384-acre parcel. There is no reference to a Blakely on the deed.

 

1

1800 Census

Martin Steele listed on the same page with Widow Blakely, William Hill, Sr & Jr., Robert Dunlap, and James Curry. 

 

1

1801

John Knox sold unknown number of acres on McDowell Creek to David Smith

PRB NOTE:  Speculate this is probably the 13-acre tract that was part of the 384-acre tract John Knox #1 purchased from Samuel Wilson in July 1800.  The 13-acre tract was bounded by Martin Steel, Adam Meek and Absalom Duck[worth] and was a 1796 State Grant to Samuel Wilson.

1

1805

John Knox sold 53 acres on the head of McDowell Creek to Robert Dunlap.  The land adjoined James Curry.  Daniel McCauly [McAuley] witnessed the transaction.  [Dunlap and Curry associated with John Knox #1; Daniel McAuley is associated with John Knox #2 and also witnessed the 1816 Original Deed in possession of the descendants of John Knox #2.]

 

1 & 2

1813

John Knox m. Polly B. Robison in Mecklenburg.

 

2

25 Dec 1816

John Knox sold to William Elliott a 105-acre parcel “on the waters of McDowell Creek  Subdivided from the plantation whereon Said John Knox now lives. Beginning at a Black Oak [Martin] STEELs Corner…to a Black Oak on Andrew Johnston’s open field…”  Daniel McAuley and Robert Meek, son of Adam Meek, witnessed the deed. A direct descendant of John Knox #2 has in his possession this 1816 original deed.  [Martin Steel and Adam Meek were among John Knox #1’s original 1800 adjoining landowners]

 

2

1818

Samuel Johnston was John Knox #1’s first Security Bondsman for the 1818 Administrators Bond for the Estate of Jane Knox, assumed sister of John Knox #1.  David Smith was his second Security Bondsman for Administration of Jane Knox’s Estate.  [Samuel Johnston is also associated with John Knox #2; his first wife, Louisa Henderson, was Polly B’s 2nd cousin]

 

1 & 2

1818

Wm. Randal & his wife Jane Randal, relict of Andw. Johnston, decd, to Saml. Johnston sold 100 acres on McDowell Creek adjoining James Bell, [John] Knox & [Alexander] Gillespie being half of the plantation formerly owned by said Andrew and bequeathed to his wife.

 

2

 

1819

James Curry [Jr] sold Samuel Johnston 126 acres adjoining Alexander Gillespie and John Knox.

 

2

1823

David Smith died and left most of his property to a nephew – James Smith, son of David’s brother William “back in Ireland”.  David also left 122 acres to Rebecca Blakely who may have been his sister… [David Smith associated with John Knox #1; James Smith was John Knox #2’s neighbor; John Knox #2 is associated with “the Blakely place”]

 

1 & 2

1823

Captain Doherty’s Company – Taxes for 1823 – Mecklenburg Co, NC

 

1 & 2

1824

State Grant to Rebecca Blakely for 50 acres on the “headwaters” of McDowell Creek

 

2

1826

John Knox appointed Guardian of Moses Shelby’s children. James Doherty is Security Bondsman. Moses Shelby m. Mary Ann Knox, assumed half-sister of John Knox, and assumed to be John’s brother-in-law.

1

1827

Moses STEEL, son of Martin, died and left this provision in his LWT -- “it is my will that my executors sell as much of my property as necessary to pay my debts, including 25 acres adjoining MARTIN STEEL’s OLD PLACE, Hugh SMITH, and JOHN KNOX.”

 

2

1828

Alexander Gillespie married John Knox #2’s sister-in-law, Elizabeth Robison.   Alexander and Elizabeth (Robison) Gillespie’s only son was Joseph Robison (J. R.) Gillespie

[Witnessed 1846 Deed between John Knox and son Robert J. Wilson Knox, see below].

 

2

1828

John Knox #2 bought from Ephraim Jetton, son of Abraham Jetton, the 105-acre parcel on the headwaters of McDowell Creek, [which John previously sold to William Elliott in 1816, and which Elliott subsequently sold to Ephraim Jetton in 1820].

 

2

1829

John Knox is included in a list of Trustees of Bethel Church who purchase Church property

 

2

1831-1844

Children and Grandchildren of Moses Shelby and Mary Ann Knox appear in Bethel Church Records

[Mary Ann Knox is the assumed half-sister of John Knox #1; but it is John Knox #2 who is a Trustee at Bethel...]

1 & 2

1834

Property of James STEEL, another son of Martin Steel, was partitioned among his heirs, including his son, Robert Ross STEELE (Sr) who was still a minor at that time.  A survey description of one of the lots provides details about the land…”being on the headwaters of McDowell Creek Beginning at a small post oak Daniel McCauley's corner...to a hickory on Hugh Smith's line...to a hickory on James G. Torrence’s line...”

 

2

1835

Sarah B. Johnston (daughter of Andrew Johnston, decd), alias Sarah B. Murray, of Cape Girardeau Co, MO sold 23 acres on the headwaters of McDowell Cr to John Knox which adjoined James H. Houston* & and “other land of John Knox.”  

 

[*James Hiram Houston’s widow, Sarah Davidson Kerr, subsequently married Major William Lee Davidson.  They were among the group who left Mecklenburg and moved to Marengo Co, Alabama.  John Knox #2’s son, Patrick J. Knox, moved to Alabama with this group after April 1846 and before the 1850 Census where he is listed as the “overseer” for the plantation of William Lee Davidson.]

 

2

1845

Robert J. Wilson Knox married Martha Nantz Jetton, daughter of Alexander Brevard Jetton and Elizabeth Nantz, granddaughter of Lewis Jetton and Priscilla Sharpe.

2

March 1846

John Knox #2 sold Robert J. W. Knox 126 acres on the headwaters of McDowell Creek adjoining lands of Wm. [Graham] Potts, John [Milton] Alexander and a “swamp”… Patrick J. Knox and J. R. Gillespie witnessed the deed. 

 

[There is no prior record of a purchase by John Knox for 126-acre parcel; therefore, this 126-acre tract was either a subdivision, or a combination, of other parcels owned by John Knox; however, the deed also does not state this parcel also adjoins John Knox.  I speculate the 126 acres +/- is the 105 acres +/- combined with the 23 acres +/- purchased from Sarah B. (Johnston) Murray, heir of Andrew Johnston who owned the adjoining property described in the 1816 deed…]

 

2

Nov 1848

Ezekiel Alexander was ordered by the court to sell the property of J[ohn]. M[ilton]. Alexander, decd. Accordingly Ezekiel Alexander conveyed to Wm. G[raham]. Potts…165 A on McDowell Creek adj James Knox, B. [sic R.] J. Knox, A SWAMP, John Knox, & other land of Wm G. Potts. 

.

2

1850

Census of Mecklenburg County, NC - Ramah District, the families of John Knox #2 and son Robert J. Wilson Knox are listed next door James Smith (brother of Hugh Smith, and nephew of David Smith, both deceased), and sisters, Eliza and Esther Smith. 

 

Listed on the same page are Ezekiel Alexander, brother of John Milton Alexander [see Nov 1848]; Joseph R. Gillespie, nephew of John and Mary; and E. A. McAuley, son of Hugh McAuley.  Robert [Ross] STEELE [Sr], his mother Elizabeth, and sisters Sarah and Jane, are also listed in the Ramah District.

 

2

June 1853

John Knox #2’s LWT item 2 states:  “I give and bequeath to my Eldest Son, Robert J Wilson [Knox] One Hundred and Twenty Six Acres of Land Known by the name of the BLAKELY place on the which he now lives and has a deed for the same…”

 

2

Oct 1853

William A Gillespie sold to Joseph R. Gillespie, 148 acres on both sides of the Great Road leading from Statesville to Charlotte…adj A[ndrew] Springs, John “or” Robert Knox, W[illiam]. G[raham]. Potts and J[oseph]. F. Gillespie [father of W. A. Gillespie]. Witnessed by R. J. W. Knox and Charles S. Potts.

 

2

July 1860

Census of Mecklenburg County, NC - Western District, John Knox #2 and Mary are living next door to Robert J. Wilson and Martha Knox.  Elizabeth STEELE, widow of James and mother of Robert Ross STEELE Sr, is living next door to Esther Smith, sister of deceased brothers Hugh and James Smith, and Uncle David Smith…and Joseph R. Robison, nephew of John Knox #2 and Mary B.

 

2

May 1860

LWT of James Smith gave “to my sister Esther Smith, during her lifetime…all my lands.  I will to John McFadden, now living in my house, and at the demise of my sister Esther, my servants James and Caleb and their mother Lucy, and my land known as the STEEL PLACE … adjoining  [D. A.] Alex CALDWELL and JOHN KNOX. 

 

2

1868

Esther Smith died in 1868, and her nephew, John McFadden, inherited the STEEL PLACE as per her brother James Smith’s 1860 LWT.  [James and Esther Smith were 1850 next-door neighbors of John Knox #2; John McFadden was John Knox #2’s descendants neighbors until 1936 when McFadden died.]

 

2

1870

Census of Mecklenburg County – Deweese Township,  Mary B. Knox, widow of John Knox #2, and grandson John A. Knox, are living next door to former Smith slaves, Lucy, James and Caleb, and John McFadden, nephew of James and Esther Smith, deceased.

 

2

1872

Robert J. Wilson Knox bought 424 acres of land on the Great Road (now Old Statesville Road), previously bequeathed to his brothers by their father John Knox #2. Adjoining property owners are D. A. Caldwell and “Smith” … 

 

[The deed for this property does not mention the “headwaters of McDowell” creek; however, a topographical map of Caldwell shows the site of “Old” John Knox’s home is on the headwaters of McDowell Creek.  This property was included in the 100 acres sold to John A. Knox by Robert J. Wilson Knox in 1873. Great grandson Wilson Knox reports there were three “strong springs” on the property which flowed into what is now called the Caldwell Branch of McDowell Creek. These springs were used to water the live stock.]

 

2

1873

Robert J. Wilson Knox sold to son, John A. Knox, 100 acres on Statesville Road adjoining D. A. Caldwell. 

 

2

1874

Mary B. (Robison) Knox, widow of John Knox #2 died. [Buried at Bethel Presbyterian, Cornelius]

 

2

1876

John Alexander Knox, grandson of John Knox #2, married Sarah Jane Blythe.

[According to Wilson Knox his grandfather, John Alexander Knox, lived in the “Old” John Knox home after John A. Knox’s grandmother Mary B. died.] 

 

2

1876

John Alexander Knox’s younger brother, Samuel Edward Knox, married Mary Ann BLAKELY, daughter of Hugh BLAKELY and Rebecca Pippens.  Hugh Blakely was the son of James BLAKELY and Mary McAuley.  James BLAKELY was the son of the Widow Rebecca BLAKELY, who was listed among the neighbors of John Knox #1 in the 1800 Census…

 

2

1880

Census of Mecklenburg County - Deweese Township, John A. and Sarah J (Blythe) Knox and their young family are living next door to John McFadden, and James Smith, a former Smith slave, and his young family.

 

2

 

 

Epilogue to a Tale...

 

Return to Site Map