| John Lindsay | 1808 |
| Phineas Camp | 1819-1822 |
| Isaac Oakes | 1824-1830 |
| Samuel G. Orton | 1831 |
| David D. Gregory, D. D. | 1833-1839 |
| Timothy M. Hopkins | 1840-1845 |
| Reuben Tinker | 1845-1854 |
| Charles F. Mussey | 1855-1861 |
| James F. Fisher | 1862-1864 |
| A. T. Chester | 1866 |
| Robert S. Van Cleve | 1867-1869 |
| Sanford H. Smith | 1869-1871 |
| E. B. Miner | 1871-1873 |
| Rufus S. Green | 1873-1877 |
| Cornelius S. Stowitts | 1879-1883 |
| William F. Faber | 1883-1892 |
| George S. Sweezey | 1893-1899 |
| George L. MacClelland | 1900-1915 |
| Alexander Thompson | 1915 -1921 |
| Charles Thompson | 1921-1926 |
| J. A. Martin | 1927-1931 |
| J. M. Spencer | 1931-1946 |
| Paul L. Denise | 1946-aft 1948 |
