Benedict Surname DNA Project
Pages
Benedict Topics Index
|
| |
Test Results Data Tables
In addition to being accessible from the Test Results page, Test Data may be reached from the following links.
The English Benedicts' data are represented here:
English Benedict Test Results
Test results for the other two groups are available here:
Other Families.
A new page, devoted to the distinction of our Project group descended from
Thomas Benedict of Norfolk, England, and Norwalk, Connecticut, as
members of the rare Haplogroup G2a1a will be found here.
Background of Our Test Results and Current Project Status
The Benedict Surname DNA Project was initiated in July 2004 as a research program to possibly discover the early
origins and international branches of the Benedict Family. The ancestry of the Benedicts has been traced by
traditional genealogical methods, primarily through wills and parish records, to a small family in early 16th century
Norfolk, England. The line was brought to America a century later (1637) by Thomas Benedict and his step-sister,
Mary Bridgham, whom he married. Thereafter, the family proliferated in America, initially in Connecticut and New York.
The DNA Project has the mission of searching for a genetic trail, laid down prior to the family's earlier emigration into
England, back through Europe. As techniques and international research programs have evolved, so too has our knowledge
of our pre-English Benedict Family origins.
Recent major Project news item indicates that all members of the
"Connecticut Sub-Group" (ie, all those descended from Thomas Benedict, the immigrant) have received as of early May 2008,
in addition to two earlier gifts, still another. At the beginning of October 2006, we learned from Family Tree DNA
that they had re-SNP-tested, without prompting, the samples of Bob (B-462) and Les (B-892). In both cases, the P15
and the P16 Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNP) were found. P16 is the defining SNP for Haplogroup G2a. In November
2006, we received notice from the Garvey Project that P18, the SNP that
defines Haplogroup G2a1, had been found in Bob's sample. Therefore, by similarity of haplotype, all members who were
previously designated only as Haplogroup G2 had gotten a "promotion" to Haplogroup G2a1. At that point, there were
fewer than a dozen men worldwide who were confirmed as G2a1. Several were field tested in the region of
Georgia/Turkey. The Garvey Project also found that Dr. David Moody, whose family line also originated in East Anglia,
about thirty miles from where the English Benedict family line originated, is also G2a1. Also, Kagan Gursel of Istambul,
Turkey, was found to be another member of G2a1. This implies that the Moody, Gursel and Benedict families have a common
ancestor. We are working on discovering where and when that ancestor lived.
In early May 2008, the International Society of Genetic Genealogy (ISOGG) issued the Y-DNA Haplogroup Tree 2008 which
contains the latest developments in a rapidly changing field. The Haplogroup G portion of the tree contains much revised data
concerning new SNPs that define new clades. As a consequence of this influx of new data the clade structure of the
haplogroup has been modified. A result of this is that former Haplogroup G2a is now redefined as 13 new sub-clades. Former
clade G2a1, to which we Benedicts belonged, is now divided into two subclades; we are now in G2a1a.
Ten members comprise the "Connecticut Sub-group," all being descended from Thomas Benedict of Norwalk, Connecticut.
They are all considered by similarity of genetic haplotype to now be of Haplogroup G2a1a.
We now have haplotype samples for each of four of the five sons of Thomas1, the English immigrant. We really
need several descendants of Thomas's son James to step forward and join the Project to help provide a fuller picture
of the genetic basis of the Benedict paternal lines. But continued representation from all five sons' descendant
lines is greatly needed and desired.
While most of the Project's members, including those not descended from Thomas Benedict, have England as their country
of ancestral origin, other countries or regions represented include the Czech Republic (Bohemia), Germany and Italy.
(For the most part, our members do not presently reside in their country of ancestral origin, but rather in Australia,
Canada and USA.)
A number of Project members are part of the National Geographic Society's Genographic Project and of other surname
projects; and some members's data are also listed on the ySearch website.
The Benedict Haplogroup
The first important milestone for the Benedict DNA Project, established in April 2005, was the confirmation
by SNP test for Bob of Haplogroup G2 (P15+) for the oldest Benedict
family line of descent (from John2) tested up to that time. We now have a new milestone with the 2006
discovery of the P16 and P18 SNPs, establishing Benedict men descended from Thomas Benedict of Connecticut
to be of the rare Haplogroup G2a1a (P18+). Other implications, primarily
historical, are under research.
It is important to emphasize, however, that not all males bearing the Benedict name are, for various
reasons, automatically members of this haplogroup (witness the case of two members of this Project,
for example). Only by actually committing to a simple Y-DNA test may a person's haplotype be identified,
thereby removing any doubts. In effect then, verifying the haplotype by test (and hence, the haplogroup)
is the ideal way to confirm (or disprove) an ancestry, either previously unknown or established by traditional
research methods.
The Benedict Haplotype
The Benedict Haplotype, as discussed here, refers to the genetic signature or "fingerpint" that,
for simplicity, identifies the male descendants of Thomas Benedict of England and Connecticut. It has been
mentioned in previous reports in terms of the differences between members of this Project based upon the
values of a few fast-evolving genetic markers on the Y-chromosome. It is obvious by examining the
Table of Test Results, however, that the members of this "Connecticut" group have more similarities
than differences. By taking the test results panels for George and Tom as the standard, then all members of this
group (except for Clark) have the STR markers 1 through 12 in common and most of the markers 24 through 37.
More variations in values are seen to occur in the middle group of markers, 13 through 25, which contains
six fast evolvers.
Based on this analysis, and until such time as much more data is received from many more lines of Benedict
descendancy, the Complete or Standard Benedict Haplotype shall be defined by that given in the
Test Results Master Table for the full 67 markers of data for Member Tom (B-166).
We can define a Generalized Benedict 56-Marker Haplotype as the set of markers expected to be exhibited by most
males surnamed Benedict who are descended from Thomas Benedict of Norfolk, England. The table for the
Generalized Benedict Haplotype includes none of the mutations seen so far in tested descendants.
For purposes of a "quick look," we also define the Shorter Benedict Haplotype as the first 25 marker
values listed in the Master Table and in the following table.
The Shorter Benedict Haplotype
Listed in FTDNA Order
Marker No. |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
7 |
8 |
9 |
10 |
11 |
12 |
13 |
14 |
15 |
16 |
17 |
18 |
19 |
20 |
21 |
22 |
23 |
24 |
25 |
DYS No. > |
393 |
390 |
19 (394) |
391 |
385 a |
385 b |
426 |
388 |
439 |
389 i |
392 |
389 ii |
458 |
459 a |
459 b |
455 |
454 |
447 |
437 |
448 |
449 |
464 a |
464 b |
464 c |
464 d |
|
Benedict Haplotype Marker Values
14 |
22 |
15 |
10 |
16 |
17 |
11 |
12 |
11 |
12 |
10 |
30 |
16 |
9 |
9 |
11 |
11 |
25 |
16 |
21 |
29 |
13 |
13 |
14 |
14 |
|
Usual G2 Marker Values
14 |
22 |
15 |
10 |
14 |
14 |
11 |
12 |
11 |
12 |
11 |
29 |
16 |
9 |
9 |
11 |
11 |
23 |
16 |
21 |
28 or 31 |
12 |
13 |
14 |
14 |
|
About Marker DYS449 and Other Fast-Evolving
Polymorphisms
It is important to understand the idea of genetic marker mutation. Markers,
scientifically called polymorphisms, are sequences of DNA proteins called Short
Tandem Repeats (STRs). Most markers remain stable (that is, constant) as they are
passed down over many generations for hundreds and even thousands of years. Some markers
(eg, for example, DYS449 and the DYS464 group) are less stable and may randomly mutate
within a shorter period of time. Knowing the rate at which such fast evolvers change
allows geneticists to estimate approximate dating for various ancestral lines. Mutations
may take the form of the substitution of a base sequence, or the insertion or deletion of
a group of STRs. The study of these genetic mutations is full of uncertainties.
The marker DYS449 (discovered in 2002) has an allele count range from about 26
alleles to 34 alleles. In the world populations tested so far, DYS449 with 29 alleles
usually occurs about 30% of the time as the most common level of mutation. But DYS449
with 28 or 30 alleles also occurs, about 20% and 21% of the time respectively. Our
test results show that most "Connecticut Benedict" members carry DYS449 at 29 alleles, the most
common count. This may indicate that this haplotype will represent the more usual
Benedict haplotype. Nevertheless, it is clear that the DYS449 marker (and in the case of Jim and
Robert, two DYS464 markers) changed for some male descendants of John, Samuel and Daniel Benedict
between the time of their birth (in the early 1600s) and the present.
Marker DYS464 is considered to be probably the fastest evolving (i.e., most polymorphic)
marker in the set of markers used for testing by Family Tree DNA. Most of the population
(more than 98%) carries four replications of this DNA segment, labeled DYS464a, 464b,
464c and 464d. A small percentage of the population (less than 2%) may have up to seven
replications. This marker is of particular interest in genetic genealogy and is
deliberately included in the test panel as a useful means of evaluating close
relationships within families and closely related groups.
The two tables below show the distribution and frequency of DYS464 alleles in the Benedict
Project and in the confirmed haplogroup G population. The reference to the "Basic" Benedict
Haplotype is to data for most Connecticut Benedict members. However, the counts of 14 alleles for
Members B-304 and B-789, Jim and Robert, are very unusual when compared to the "Basic" Benedict
Haplotype as well as the population at large. Without considerably more data, both for the "Samuel"
line and from parallel family lines, it is difficult to guess when these mutations might have occurred.
Historically, the Samuel line started later in time than the lines from John, but before the line of
Thomas's son Daniel. At this time, with insufficient data, these DYS464 mutations for the Samuel line
present a mystery.
Benedict DYS464 Allele Counts
DYS No. > |
464 a |
464 b |
464 c |
464 d |
Predicted Haplogroup |
|
"Basic" Benedict Allele Count |
13 |
13 |
14 |
14 |
G2 |
"Samuel Line" Allele Count |
14 |
14 |
14 |
14 |
G2 |
DYS464 Frequency in Haplogroup G Population
DYS No. > |
464 a |
464 b |
464 c |
464 d |
Allele Count |
Frequency ( % ) |
|
12 Repeats |
84 |
8 |
3 |
- |
13 Repeats |
13 |
76 |
71 |
11 |
14 Repeats |
Very Rare |
13 |
37 |
74 |
15 Repeats |
- |
3 |
5 |
13 |
Frequency data courtesy of W. Athey
|
|